Public Disclosure Commission: No further investigation of 'Rain Shadow Report'

Yakima City Council candidate Keith Effler reaches settlement in Rain Shadow Report lawsuit

The strange story of The Rain Shadow Report - Oct. 16th, 2017

Just before the August 1st primary election, registered voters in Yakima District 4 received a newsprint mailing titled The Rain Shadow Report. It is a violation of campaign laws to send campaign literature disguised as a neutral source and without a disclosure statement such as, “This statement is paid for by the Keith Effler Campaign”. It is unlawful to make false and damaging statements about other candidates (calling Chelsea Mack a “socialist”) without taking responsibility.

Since then, Keith falsely stated that he was not involved in The Rain Shadow Report, even though the Herald-Republic took the printing order directly from him. He repeatedly complained of being “accused” of involvement. It was not until last week that he admitted his role, and that the anonymous editor is Jared Bower, his Campaign Treasurer and the pastor of “Conquest Church, LLC”.

Now he has paid a  $9,412.52 settlement to compensate the District 4 voters who were deceived. But he continues to deny guilt. These are facts, and FACTS MATTER.

You can read the full text and the court order here: /UserFiles/files/Galusha_Effler_Settlement_package_FINAL_(1).pdf

Regarding Conquest Church, LLC:

We wrote and sent this Letter to the Editor of the Yakima Herald-Republic on 7/16/17. It was printed, after editorial cuts, on 7/26/2017.

To the Editor:

I am writing in response to the 7/16/17 Letter to the Editor from Philip Ostriem.

Keith Effler, who is running for Yakima City Council in District 4, and Micaela Razo, who is running in District 6 have both taken campaign contributions from the Conquest Church LLC. Philip Ostriem is named as a “manager” in their articles of incorporation, which can be seen here:

The "registered agent" of Conquest Church LLC is Jared Bower, who is also Keith's campaign treasurer. This group has several videos on youtube, in which they talk about fielding and supporting candidates for local elected office. In some of these, Keith is in the room.

Even more weird is their video series called "Demonic Warfare", in which Jared Bower talks about the importance of exorcising demons. He also talks about exorcising demonic influences from public life.

For my own full disclosure, I have been married for 43 years to Kay Funk, MD, who is also a candidate in District 4. You can visit the campaign website at:

Mike Collins,



Regarding The Rain Shadow Report:

I doubt that Keith realized what he was doing when he wandered into this. However, when I make statements about racial profiling and ICE cooperation, I know that some people will oppose those statements, so I think carefully about the law and long term strategy. This is an important part of my decision-making process over my 35 years of working in medicine.

Separation of church and state is the first sentence in the Bill of Rights, so mingling religion with civic life should raise huge red flags in the mind of any candidate for public office, and that person should think carefully about potential violation of the law. Keith, apparently, does not have that capacity to be cautious or self-critical. If elected, he will carry that carelessness to the city council.

I am not anti-Christian. I appreciate the morality lessons of the New Testament. Faith based organizations can generate a lot of positive enthusiasm. But when that group bonding turns into Groupthink bad things happen. Yakima already has serious questions about stealthy church involvement in the homeless service projects which have been awarded public money. There are lines which should not be crossed, and those need to be carefully watched.

Other articles:

Yakima City Council candidate complies with PDC request to amend finance report

Expert says candidate's involvement in 'Rain Shadow Report' inappropriate, could break state law

Yakima City Council candidate says he wasn’t involved with ‘Rain Shadow’

Violation of election law :

YHR article on Conquest Church, LLC, campaign contributions :

Yakima Business Times


Political advertisement paid for and approved by the candidate.
Campaign Websites by Online Candidate